Silver Diamine Fluoride Halted More Cavities Than Placebo in Young Children

 ·  Last updated

CATEGORY: DISEASE PREVENTION

A liquid brushed painlessly onto a cavity stopped the decay in 50.2% of treated baby teeth after eight months, against 17.4% of teeth that received a placebo, in a randomized trial of 830 young children.1 The liquid is silver diamine fluoride. A gap of 32.8 percentage points works out to roughly 33 more cavities halted for every 100 treated. No drill, no injection, no anesthetic.

A Few Seconds Per Tooth

Silver diamine fluoride is a clear liquid pairing two ingredients. Silver kills the bacteria driving the decay, and fluoride helps harden the damaged tooth surface. Applying it takes a tiny sponge-tipped brush and a few seconds per tooth, about as long as painting a fingernail.

830 Children, Three States, Two Coats

The children were aged one to six and had severe early childhood caries, meaning advanced decay of the baby teeth, averaging about 11 affected teeth per child. Each child’s cavities got either a 38% silver diamine fluoride solution or a placebo made to look just like it, decided at random, painted on once at enrollment and then repeated six months later. Families and the dentists scoring the teeth were both kept in the dark. Recruiting ran through dental offices, pediatric medical practices and Head Start preschool programs in Michigan, New York and Iowa. Examiners rechecked every treated tooth at three, six and eight months for the trial’s main outcome: whether the cavity had stopped progressing.

Half the Cavities Hardened and Stopped

An arrested cavity is one whose decayed surface has hardened so the damage no longer advances. By three months, 57.5% of cavities treated with the liquid had arrested, against 18.8% in the placebo group. The gap held to the end. At eight months it was 50.2% against 17.4%, a difference of 32.8 percentage points that the study placed between about 22 and 43 points. Side effects were no more common with the real treatment than with the placebo. Some adverse event occurred in 47.3% of children in the silver diamine fluoride group, nearly all of it minor, against 43.3% with placebo. Reports of dental pain did not differ.

The treatment’s one conspicuous drawback is cosmetic. Silver diamine fluoride permanently stains the decayed portion of the tooth black. The stain marks only the damaged area, not the healthy enamel around it, and because these are baby teeth, the stained tooth is eventually shed on nature’s own schedule. The standard alternative for severe early decay is drilling and filling, which in one- to three-year-olds frequently requires general anesthesia. That is the comparison the trial puts in front of a family.

An Off-Label Standby Heading for Approval

Silver diamine fluoride is not new to American dental chairs. It has been cleared since 2014 as a device for treating tooth sensitivity, and dentists have used it off-label against cavities for years. What was missing is the large, placebo-controlled evidence that formal approval as a decay treatment requires, and this NIH-funded trial was run to supply exactly that. Its authors conclude the results support pursuing FDA approval for arresting cavities in young children. A second trial points the same way. In a pragmatic school-based study of nearly 3,000 New York City schoolchildren, a single yearly application kept pace with the standard combination of dental sealants and fillings at arresting existing decay over two years.2

Key Takeaways

  • Silver diamine fluoride halted about half of treated cavities over eight months in 830 children under six with severe early decay, against fewer than one in five on placebo, a difference of 32.8 percentage points.
  • Side effects matched placebo and dental pain did not differ between groups. The one lasting drawback is a permanent black stain on the decayed part of the tooth, which leaves with the baby tooth itself.
  • The liquid has been used off-label in the United States since 2014. This trial was designed to support full FDA approval, and a separate school-based trial found it kept pace with sealants and fillings in older children.

References

  1. Fontana M, Moursi A, Gonzalez-Cabezas C, et al. Efficacy of Silver Diamine Fluoride on Young Children With Severe Early Childhood Caries: A Randomized Clinical Trial. JAMA Pediatrics. Published online July 27, 2026. doi:10.1001/jamapediatrics.2026.2567. link
  2. Ruff RR, Barry-Godín T, Niederman R. Effect of Silver Diamine Fluoride on Caries Arrest and Prevention: The CariedAway School-Based Randomized Clinical Trial. JAMA Network Open. 2023;6(2):e2255458. link